Butch Garcia hit well early in minors for Indians; Played across eight seasons, made AAA

-


Butch Garcia got off to a hot start his first year as a pro. In 60 games at short-season Batavia in 1984, Garcia hit .347 in 60 games, tops in the circuit in mid-August.

Garcia could hardly believe it, he told his hometown Tampa Tribune then.

"Sometimes it seems like a dream that I'm leading the league in hitting," Garcia told The Tribune. "I'm hitting the ball as good as I ever have."

Garcia went on from that first year to see time across eight pro seasons. He made it up to AAA, but he never made the majors.

Garcia's career began in 1984, taken by the Indians in the second round of the January draft out of Palm Beach Community College in Florida.

Garcia went to Palm Beach Community out of Hillsborough County's Leto High School. He gained notice even as a junior in 1982.

His head coach  there, Mike Notaro, praised Garcia to the Tribune that February, noting that even though he was better than his teammates, he still worked harder than anyone.

"That's special when you have a kid that knows he's better than most but can never get enough work," Notaro told The Tribune.

Garcia started with the Indians at Batavia. After that hitting display, he moved to single-A Waterloo, where he hit .259 in 113 games. 

After losing 1986 to a broken thumb, he returned to the field for 1987 with the Cubs at single-A Peoria. He hit .263, with 16 home runs.

He played 1988 at high-A Winston-Salem, then 1989 between AA Charlotte and AAA Iowa. In 47 games at Iowa, Garcia hit .195.

That April, Garcia came into a game as a late-inning replacement, then hit a three-run home run to give Iowa the lead, The Des Moines Register wrote.

"I guessed right," Garcia told The Register afterward of the home run. "I was watching (Doug) Dascenzo bat before me. (The pitcher) was having trouble getting his fastball over the plate, so I was sitting for a changeup and I got it."

He returned to Charlotte for 1990, where he got into 63 games and hit .212. He then is recorded as playing 1991 in Mexico for Union Laguna and Saltillo, marking the end of his career.

1990 Minor League Tally
Players/Coaches Featured:3,587
Made the Majors:1,244-34.7%
Never Made Majors:2,343-65.3%-X
5+ Seasons in the Majors:517
10+ Seasons in the Minors:305

Browse By:

-Player Name
-Player Team
-Date Featured

Players A to Z

Popular posts from this blog

Road Trip: Trenton Thunder

-
Image
Blue Jays catching coordinator Sal Fasano, right, at the batting cage before a game at Trenton's Arm & Hammer Park in June 2014. (G21D Photo) When my wife and I were in Baltimore in 2005, the Red Sox were in town playing the Orioles. At one point during the game, the Red Sox player walked up to the plate and tapped the catcher on the shoulder in a gesture of recognition. I remember telling my wife about it later. The two players were Johnny Damon and Sal Fasano . Both players came up in the Royals system and played together there. I found it cool and interesting, especially because I'd seen Fasano play years before, when my dad and I frequented Cedar Rapids Kernels games in 1994. Fasano played that year for the Rockford Royals , winning the league's MVP . I mention all this because I had the opportunity to cross paths with Fasano again unexpectedly this past weekend. Fasano, with his distinctive mustache, served as the fill-in manager for the New Hampshir...
Read more

Chris Sparrow came back from slump with home run at Utica; Played two pro seasons

-
Image
Chris Sparrow had his first big game in a while in this July 1990 contest for Utica as he went 2 for 4, with a home run, The Elmira Star-Gazette wrote . "I just haven't been in a groove," Sparrow explained to The Star-Gazette afterward. "I hurt my right knee earlier and after coming back, I've been 0-for-12. But maybe this will get me out of the slump." Sparrow ended up coming back to hit .281 on the year, but it wasn't enough. That year marked his second pro season, but also his last . He topped out at short-season. Sparrow's career began in 1989, signed by the Braves as a free agent out of the University of North Carolina-Asheville. Sparrow played summer 1989 with the American Legion team in his hometown of Kernersville. He hit a three-run home run in an August game.  With the Braves, Sparrow played at rookie Idaho Falls . That July, he hit a fastball out for a home run off Salt Lake starter Tom Studstill, The Salt Lake Tribune wrote . "Th...
Read more

Willie Canate made one ML season, also saw World Series

-
Image
New Blue Jay Willie Canate wasn't expecting to play in this July 1993 game, but, in the end, he helped his team win, The Associated Press wrote . Canate came off the bench due to injury to tie the game with a single early and then hit his first major league home run to win the game late, The AP wrote . "I was happy because the start wasn't anticipated," Canate told The AP , through an interpreter. "I'm just thrilled to death to be able to help the team win. Hopefully this will lead to more opportunities to play." Canate did get some more opportunities to play, including one brief appearance later that year in the World Series. But his major league career proved confined to that single season. Canate's career began in 1989, signed by the Indians as a free agent out of his native Venezuela . Canate started with the Indians in the rookie Gulf Coast League . He moved to short-season Watertown for 1990 and then single-A Columbus and high-A Kinston in 1...
Read more

A to Z: 1990 Minor League Players, Baseball Profiles

-
Image
What happened to your favorite minor league team in 1990? Find out here. Since late 2009, the players of 1990 have been featured at Greatest21Days.com, one at a time. Here, they've been ordered here alphabetically.  Every player has a story. With the help of contemporaneous newspaper articles, find that story here. Most recent players added Aug. 16, 2025 List of 1990 minor league players featured, in alphabetical order: Total: 4,457 A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z A  -  Bill Abare  got big hit at Dunedin, saw three pro seasons, 10/31/13  -  Glenn Abbott  saw bigs over decade, later turned coach, 7/27/14  -  Kurt Abbott 's first ML hit went for homer, saw 9 seasons, 3/22/15  -  Kyle Abbott  saw time in four major league seasons, Japan, 10/4/17  -  Paul Abbott  returned from injuries, made 11 ML seasons, 5/23/11 ...
Read more

1990 Wichita Wranglers player profiles, AA San Diego

-
Image
Features on each member of the 1990 Wichita Wranglers, AA affiliate of the San Diego Padres, as included in that year's team set. Wichita Wranglers (28) Andy Benes  made the Olympics, then bigs over 14 seasons Ricky Bones  used luck, opportunity over 11 majors seasons Doug Brocail  saw 15 major league campaigns, later coached Rafael Chaves  made AA as player, bigs as coach, cried Brian Cisarik  hit well in college, played 5 pro seasons Wichita Wranglers mascot  Cookie  had versatile performers Greg David  learned pro realities over 8 seasons, made AA Todd Hansen  knew he had to pitch well in 1987 start; Saw pros over seven seasons, made AA , 10/20/20 Jeremy Hernandez  moved from starting to relief and then made the bigs over five seasons , 3/30/20 Charlie Hillemann  made AAA, later decided to quit baseball, go home and be a dad , 11/2/20 Rich Holsman  liked to play the game, did so over five seasons; Made AA , 10/30/20 Mike Hum...
Read more

Julio Valera made 5 bigs seasons with 'dastardly dip' slider

-
Image
Once a Mets starting prospect, Julio Valera now found himself with the Angels. He also found himself thrust into a game, unsure exactly how to handle relief duties. "After the first pitch," Valera told The Los Angeles Times in April 1992, "I said to myself, 'This is just another game. Go right at them.' After that, I got my fastball over and all my pitches over." Valera had just been traded to the Angels earlier that month by a Mets team that had grown wary of his arm . Signed by the Mets in 1986 as a free agent out of Puerto Rico, Valera developed, by one account , a slider with a "dastardly dip." Three seasons in the low minors gave way in 1989 to promotion to AA Jackson and a taste of AAA Tidewater. He returned to Tidewater for 1990, making his Mets debut as a September call-up. In six innings, Valera gave up five hits and three runs, a quality start that had the Mets impressed, according to the New York Times . ''...
Read more

1990 Eugene Emeralds player profiles, Royals

-
Image
Features on each member of the 1990 Eugene Emeralds, short-season affiliate of the Kansas City Royals. Eugene Emeralds (30) 1 -  Javier Alvarez  saw two pro seasons with Royals at Eugene 2 -  Francisco Baez  saw 5 pro seasons with Royals, made high-A 3 -  Ramy Brooks  grew up in college, saw 9 pro seasons, AAA 4 -  Jay Carballo  learned lessons in college, saw single season 5 -  Scott Davis  broke bats as pitcher, played one pro season 6 -  Weddison Ebanks , Brief Stay, 9/9/18 7 -  Charles Frederick , Little Mistake, 9/25/18 8 -  Sean Franceschi , Tough Start, 8/7/18 9 -  Harry Guanchez , Home Run, 9/28/18 10 -  Rafael Gutierrez , Crowd Size, 9/29/18 11 -  David Haber , Big Game, 10/6/18 12 -  Donny Harrel , Best Thing, 7/19/18 13 -  Doug Harris , His Job, 10/10/18 14 -  Phil Hiatt , On Numbers, 7/30/18 15 -  Dave Hierholzer , Vulture Wins, 8/31/18 16...
Read more