Butch Garcia hit well early in minors for Indians; Played across eight seasons, made AAA

-


Butch Garcia got off to a hot start his first year as a pro. In 60 games at short-season Batavia in 1984, Garcia hit .347 in 60 games, tops in the circuit in mid-August.

Garcia could hardly believe it, he told his hometown Tampa Tribune then.

"Sometimes it seems like a dream that I'm leading the league in hitting," Garcia told The Tribune. "I'm hitting the ball as good as I ever have."

Garcia went on from that first year to see time across eight pro seasons. He made it up to AAA, but he never made the majors.

Garcia's career began in 1984, taken by the Indians in the second round of the January draft out of Palm Beach Community College in Florida.

Garcia went to Palm Beach Community out of Hillsborough County's Leto High School. He gained notice even as a junior in 1982.

His head coach  there, Mike Notaro, praised Garcia to the Tribune that February, noting that even though he was better than his teammates, he still worked harder than anyone.

"That's special when you have a kid that knows he's better than most but can never get enough work," Notaro told The Tribune.

Garcia started with the Indians at Batavia. After that hitting display, he moved to single-A Waterloo, where he hit .259 in 113 games. 

After losing 1986 to a broken thumb, he returned to the field for 1987 with the Cubs at single-A Peoria. He hit .263, with 16 home runs.

He played 1988 at high-A Winston-Salem, then 1989 between AA Charlotte and AAA Iowa. In 47 games at Iowa, Garcia hit .195.

That April, Garcia came into a game as a late-inning replacement, then hit a three-run home run to give Iowa the lead, The Des Moines Register wrote.

"I guessed right," Garcia told The Register afterward of the home run. "I was watching (Doug) Dascenzo bat before me. (The pitcher) was having trouble getting his fastball over the plate, so I was sitting for a changeup and I got it."

He returned to Charlotte for 1990, where he got into 63 games and hit .212. He then is recorded as playing 1991 in Mexico for Union Laguna and Saltillo, marking the end of his career.

1990 Minor League Tally
Players/Coaches Featured:3,587
Made the Majors:1,244-34.7%
Never Made Majors:2,343-65.3%-X
5+ Seasons in the Majors:517
10+ Seasons in the Minors:305

Browse By:

-Player Name
-Player Team
-Date Featured

Players A to Z

Popular posts from this blog

Features from the 1990 minor league sets (By Date)

-
Image
What happened to your favorite minor league team in 1990? Find out here. Since late 2009, the players of 1990 have been featured at Greatest21Days.com, one at a time. Here, they've been ordered here by the date published, newest first.  Every player has a story. With the help of contemporaneous newspaper articles, find that story here. Most recent players added July 13 ,  2025 Features in order of when the y appeared: July 2025 Trenidad Hubbard  dreamed, made bigs over 10 seasons,  7/13/25 Glenn Davis  got help, went from tough youth to ML star, 7/12/25 Matt Rambo   had jitters early, saw 5 seasons, AA, injury, 7/9/25 Bryan Foster  improved enough for 5 pro seasons, high-A, 7/6/25 T.J. Lucin  hoped to be FMLBBP, saw 2 seasons, single-A, 7/5/25 Edwin Valentin  saw 3 seasons, single-A, from Puerto Rico, 7/1/25 June 2025 Perry Berry  saw 4 seasons, high-A, went into education , 6/30/25 Jorge Pineda  made perfect throw, played one pr...
Read more

Interview: Joe Xavier followed first love, baseball, to pros

-
Image
Patti and Joe Xavier outside a Starbucks in Fowler, Ca. Joe Xavier played six seasons as a pro, making it as high as AAA. (G21D Photo) FOWLER, CA - When Joe Xavier was a boy, he had something other kids didn't: An uncle in the major leagues. For Xavier, it seemed normal. It was also his first introduction into baseball. "To see that right off, you don't know any better, Major League Baseball, was quite something," Xavier recalled to The Greatest 21 Days recently. "So that was my introduction. After that, that was pretty much my first love." Xavier went from there to make his own bid at the majors, to follow in the footsteps of his uncle, Bobby Cox . Xavier, though, would never make the bigs, playing six seasons as a pro, but never making it past AAA. Xavier met up with The Greatest 21 Days in late July with his wife Patti at a Starbucks in Fowler, Ca., near his hometown of Selma. Xavier covered his origins in the game, his route through Cal...
Read more

A to Z: 1990 Minor League Players, Baseball Profiles

-
Image
What happened to your favorite minor league team in 1990? Find out here. Since late 2009, the players of 1990 have been featured at Greatest21Days.com, one at a time. Here, they've been ordered here alphabetically.  Every player has a story. With the help of contemporaneous newspaper articles, find that story here. Most recent players added Aug. 16, 2025 List of 1990 minor league players featured, in alphabetical order: Total: 4,457 A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z A  -  Bill Abare  got big hit at Dunedin, saw three pro seasons, 10/31/13  -  Glenn Abbott  saw bigs over decade, later turned coach, 7/27/14  -  Kurt Abbott 's first ML hit went for homer, saw 9 seasons, 3/22/15  -  Kyle Abbott  saw time in four major league seasons, Japan, 10/4/17  -  Paul Abbott  returned from injuries, made 11 ML seasons, 5/23/11 ...
Read more

1990 Southern Oregon Athletics player profiles, Oakland

-
Image
Features on each member of the 1990 Southern Oregon Athletics, short-season affiliate of the Oakland Athletics. 1990 Southern Oregon Athletics (33) 1  -  Eric Booker  saw five pro seasons, made AA with Athletics 2  -  Brad Brimhall  played in minors to make majors, made high-A 3  -  Scott Budner  played, then helped others to majors as coach 4  -  Jeff Clifford  played single season, in Athletics system 5  -  Craig Connolly  used good pitches to make 4 pro seasons 6  -  Mark Craft  played two sports at VMI, baseball as pro 7  -  Kevin Dattola  played over 13 seasons, made AAA, Korea 8 - Jim Dillon, That Opportunity Jim Dillon stayed in college and improved his draft spot. He played three pro seasons. 9 - Kirk Dressendorfer, Different Life Kirk Dressendorfer made the majors quickly, then injuries came. Never made it back. 10 - Grady Fuson, Hung In Grady Fuson hung in ...
Read more

1990 Niagara Falls Rapids player profiles, Detroit Tigers

-
Image
Features on each member of the 1990 Niagara Falls Rapids, as included in the 1990 team set of the short-season NY-Penn League affiliate of the Detroit Tigers. Niagara Falls Rapids (34) Francisco Alcantara  proved workhorse over two pro seasons Greg Coppeta  made college Hall of Fame, 4 pro seasons AA Genaro DeBrand  saw one minor league season with Tigers Joe Decker  pitched one way over 9 bigs seasons, coached Joe DeDario  performed for Niagara Falls Rapids, loved it Dinger the Duck  had some competition in Niagara Falls as mascot; He and team stayed five seasons , 4/22/20 Tom Drell  got off to a good start at high-A, then he walked away; He no longer found joy playing , 5/10/20 Rob Fazekas  pitched better than his record in college; Played two seasons as a pro , 4/20/20 Fielder's Choice Baseball Cards  sponsored the 1990 Niagara Falls Rapids card set; Neither remains in Niagara Falls , 4/13/20 Kevin Keon  helped his colle...
Read more

Jody Treadwell concentrated, saw 11 seasons, AAA, Taiwan

-
Image
New Vero Beach Dodger Jody Treadwell admitted to The Indian River Press Journal to being a little jittery. This game in late June 1990 was his first pro start , after all. "I just concentrated on getting ahead of the hitters," Treadwell told The Press Journal afterward. "I knew as long as I did that, I'd be OK." Treadwell eventually was OK enough to see the pros over 11 seasons . He spent six of those at AAA and one in Taiwan, but missed the majors. Treadwell's career began that year in 1990, taken by the Dodgers in the 27th round of the draft out of Jacksonville University in Florida. Treadwell started at high-A Vero Beach . He went 9-1 over 16 outings, eight starts. He ended with a 1.79 ERA. He played 1991 between high-A Bakersfield and AA San Antonio. He went 8-7 between them, with a 4.14 ERA. Treadwell returned to San Antonio for all of 1992, then hit AAA Albuquerque for 1993. He then stayed with Albuquerque through 1997 - five total seasons. In 199...
Read more

1990 Syracuse Chiefs player profiles, AAA Blue Jays

-
Image
Features on each member of the 1990 Syracuse Chiefs, AAA affiliate of the Toronto Blue Jays. Interviews (2) 1 - Webster Garrison, Every Day Webster Garrison sometimes decided he was tired of baseball. He kept playing. And he made the majors. 2 - Tom Gilles, Seventh Tryout Tom Gilles' major league career was short, just two games, but he got there by being convinced he should be. 1990 Syracuse Chiefs (31) 1  -  Bob Bailor  played long time, returned to majors as coach 2  -  Derek Bell  saw 11 ML seasons, then ended with 'shutdown' 3  -  Steve Cummings  made majors with Blue Jays for 11 games 4  -  Hector De La Cruz  played in minors, Taiwan, then managed 5 - Carlos Diaz, Grief Stay Carlos Diaz was itching to start after college. He made the majors for nine games. 6 - Rob Ducey, Big Responsibility Rob Ducey put pressure on himself in 1997. He only was filling in for Ken Griffey Jr. 7 - Andy Dziadkowiec, Thir...
Read more