But, in early 1989, that's exactly what happened to University of Central Florida pitcher Brian Ahern: In a practice game, a aluminum bat broke in two, according to The Orlando Sentinel.
"I think it was more the hitter. He swung, and the bat flew out toward me," Ahern told The Sentinel. "I've never seen it happen before, but apparently other people have."
Ahern soon had the chance to break bats in the pros, taken by the Royals in the fifth round of that June's draft out of Central Florida.
Ahern, though, would never get the opportunity to break bats in the majors, getting to AAA, but no higher.
Ahern began his pro career at short-season Eugene, starting 13 games and going 4-5. He moved to single-A Appleton for 1990, getting just 11 starts on the year, going 2-9. His ERA there was 5.12.
Ahern split 1991 between Appleton and high-A Baseball City. He went 9-6 between them, with a 3.11 ERA.
For 1992, Ahern made AA Memphis for the first time. He also made AAA Omaha. At Memphis, he went 6-2, with a 2.54 ERA. At Omaha, he went 7-5, with a 4.02 ERA.
Then came a surgery to remove a bone spur in his elbow. Ahern never pitched as well afterward, he told The Sentinel later.
He went 5-11 in 23 starts in 1993 between Memphis and Omaha. It was his last year in affiliated ball.
Ahern moved to independent Thunder Bay in 1994, then tried his hand in replacement ball with the Blue Jays in spring 1995.
"I just want to put it (his arm) to the test and see where it's going to lead," Ahern told The Sentinel of why he was there that spring. "If I was in a situation doing well and with an organization, who knows, maybe my decision would have been a little harder and maybe even different. It's a no-brainer for me right now. I have no reservations about giving myself the best opportunity I can to succeed."
Ahern's opportunity, though, led to another year in the independent leagues, with the Texas-Louisiana League. It was his last year in the pros.
- Orlando Sentinel, Feb. 5, 1989: UCF's Ahern Hopes To Break Opponents' Hearts
- Orlando Sentinel, March 23, 1995: Ahern's Story No Fairy Tale
Cards Featured: 783/880 - 89.0%
Players/Coaches Featured: 794
Made the Majors: 541 - 68%
Never Made the Majors:253-32%-X
5+ Seasons in the Majors: 240
10+ Seasons in the Minors: 147