Then, after several things fell into place, Benes had put up stats in college that caught everyone's attention, including the Padres', who made him the first-overall pick in the 1988 draft, Scripps Howard wrote.
"I couldn't ask to do anything else," Benes told the news service as he prepared to represent the United States on the 1988 Olympic baseball team. "I have to pinch myself every once in a while to make sure I'm not dreaming."
Benes wasn't dreaming. And he went on from the Olympics and that top selection to a career that saw him make the majors over 14 seasons, win 155 big league games and make an All-Star team.
Benes' career began that year in 1988, taken by the Padres in that top slot of the draft out of the University of Evansville.
After the Padres drafted him, readied for the Seoul games and then helped the squad to Olympic gold. In one 12-2 win over Australia, he went 6.2 and gave up two runs.
He started with the Padres in 1989 at AA Wichita. (His time there and status appear to have gotten him a card in their 1990 set, the checklist card.) He also briefly saw AAA Las Vegas before he debuted by mid-August. He then never looked back.
Benes got 10 starts, going 6-3, with a 3.51 ERA for the Padres. He then went 10-11 over 31 starts in 1990, with a 3.60 ERA.
He threw his first complete game in May 1990, a two-hitter over Philadelphia, and he earned the respect of the opposing starter Pat Combs, according to The Associated Press.
"He's always been a power pitcher who can dominate when he has his good stuff," Combs told The AP afterward. "Tonight was a good example. He'll be a good one."
Benes then picked up 15 wins in 1991 and 13 in 1992. In 1993, he went 15-15, with a 3.78 ERA and made the All-Star team.
He continued with the Padres into 1995, when the Padres traded him to the Mariners mid-year. He then signed with the Cardinals for 1996.
Benes went a career-best 18-10 in 1996 for the Cardinals, with a 3.83 ERA. He also came in third in the Cy Young voting.
He stayed with St. Louis for 1997, then spent two years with the Diamondbacks before he signed back with the Cardinals for 2000. He went 12-9 that year and helped keep St. Louis alive in the NLCS against the Mets with an eight-inning, 8-2 win.
"I'm just thankful for the opportunity," Benes told reporters afterward. "It was a neat to get the opportunity to pitch in a game this big, in a great arena, in New York. I wouldn't trade it for anything."
Benes then saw 27 outings in 2001 and 18 more in 2002 to end his career.
- Miami News, Scripps Howard News Service, Sept. 7, 1988: Andy Benes a throwback to All-American boy-next-door era
- Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, Associated Press, May 16, 1990: SD's Benes takes fifth on middle inning
- ESPN, Oct. 14, 2000: Benes keeps Cardinals off endangered list
Made the Majors:1,222-34.9%-X
Never Made Majors:2,282-65.1%
5+ Seasons in the Majors:509-X
10+ Seasons in the Minors:299