But the two games he didn't save are perhaps the games he's best remembered for, where the Dodger closer gave up two key home runs to the Cardinals in the 1985 National League Championship Series.
"Looking back on it," Niedenfuer told The Los Angeles Times a quarter century later, "it's a very proud feeling that your manager had enough confidence in you to be the guy he put in that situation. I wouldn't trade that for anything in the world because I loved being out there. But when it happened, all I can remember is … you let the team down."
Niedenfuer saw time in 484 major league games in all over 10 seasons. He saved 97, including a career high 19 in 1985.
Niedenfuer's career began in 1980, signed by the Dodgers as an amateur free agent out of Washington State University.
He hit the field in 1981, starting AA San Antonio. He then quickly made Los Angeles. He debuted in mid-August and got into 17 games. He went 3-1, with a 3.81 ERA.
Niedenfuer also saw time in the 1981 postseason for the Dodgers. He got into four games, two of them in the World Series. He gave up no earned runs in five innings of work in the Fall Classic.
Niedenfuer returned to the Dodgers full-time in 1982. He got into 55 games that year and 66 the next. He went 8-3 in 1983 and saved 11 games.
He struck out seven in four innings of work in an August 1983 game. "I had good control and a lot of rest," Niedenfuer told The Associated Press afterward.
Neidenfuer got into 64 games in 1985 and saved those 19. His postseason trouble began in Game 5 of the NLCS when he gave up a walk-off home run to Ozzie Smith. Then, two days later in Game 6, he gave up another ninth-inning home run, this one a three-run shot to Jack Clark.
"Nobody feels worse in the entire United States than he does," Dodgers manager Tommy Lasorda told reporters later. "He feels worse than anybody."
Niedenfuer stayed with the Dodgers into 1987, when they traded him to the Orioles. He saved 18 games for Baltimore in 1988 in limited chances.
He then played two more seasons in the majors, 1989 with the Mariners and 1990 with the Cardinals. He got into 52 games for St. Louis, as well as five at AAA Louisville, in 1990, ending his career.
- Greenville Daily Advocate, Associated Press, Aug. 12, 1983: Cincy tries for sweep, but Dodgers hang on
- South Florida Sun-Sentinel, Oct. 17, 1985: 'Show Me' Series
- Los Angeles Times, Oct. 10, 2010: Tom Neidenfuer remembers but doesn't dwell on fateful pitches
Players/Coaches Featured: 2,734
Made the Majors:1,045-38.2%-X
Never Made Majors:1,689-61.8%
5+ Seasons in the Majors: 434-X
10+ Seasons in the Minors:263