"I've been trying to overthrow the ball," Ayala told The Associated Press after a late-July contest. "I can't overthrow the ball and be successful."
Ayala would go on to save 19 for the Mariners that year, after saving 18 for them the previous campaign.
But the problems that showed themselves early in that 1995 season would persist, showing themselves again in some of the worst possible moments, as the Mariners made the franchise's first playoff run.
And with that, Ayala's major league career that spanned eight seasons continues to hold the ire of an entire fan base.
Ayala's career began in 1988, signed by the Reds as a free agent out of Rio Mesa High School in California.
He started in the rookie Gulf Coast League, moving to single-A Greensboro in 1989 and then single-A Cedar Rapids in 1990. He made AA Chattanooga in 1991 and 1992, then, in September 1992, he made Cincinnati.
That first September in the majors, Ayala started five games for the Reds, going 2-1, with a 4.34 ERA. He moved to relief in 1993 as he returned to the Reds, getting into 43 games, starting just nine. Overall, he went 7-10, with a 5.60 ERA.
For 1994, Ayala arrived with the Mariners in a four-player deal. By the end of April, Ayala was Seattle's closer. Holding a Seattle lead through two innings of work against the Red Sox sealed the new title, according to The AP.
"I was very confident when I went in there," Ayala told The AP. "I had great control of my pitches. You can't do any better than that."
Ayala ended up getting into a total of 46 games in that strike-shortened year for the Mariners. He ultimately saved 18 games and posted a 2.86 ERA.
Then came his 1995 season, one where Ayala saved 19, with an ERA of 4.44, seeing his Mariners win the American League West.
Then, in the Mariners' first-ever playoff game, Ayala ended up giving up three earned runs against the Yankees, while getting just a single out. The Yankees won 9-6.
"Every pitch they hit was up," Mariners pitching coach Bobby Cuellar told The Seattle Post-Intelligencer after the game. "He is throwing his forkball too hard and not giving it a chance to break."
The Mariners ended up coming back on the Yankees and making the ALCS and Ayala pitched well enough there. Between games 2 and 4, Ayala went 3.2 innings, giving up one earned run. He also walked three. Both outings came in losses and the Mariners ultimately lost the series to the Indians.
Ayala stayed with the Mariners through 1998, his ERA hitting 5.88 in 50 1996 outings, then 3.82 in 71 1997 outings.
The 1997 season saw Ayala and the Mariners return to the playoffs. Ayala's return went about as well as his first time there. In just one outing, 1.1 innings of work against the Orioles, Ayala gave up six earned runs.
Ayala's postseason performances still had Mariners fans talking years later, with The Seattle Times noting some counted him among the franchise's "irredeemable villains."
Ayala played just two more seasons. In 1998, Ayala returned to the Mariners and got into 62 games. He also lost 10 and had an ERA that exploded to 7.29. His final big league career came in 1999, splitting 66 outings between the Expos and the Cubs. One more season, spent in the minors, and Ayala's career was done.
- Nashua Telegraph, Associated Press, April 28, 1994: Perfect ending for Mariners' Ayala against Sox
- Moscow-Pullman Daily News, Associated Press, July 26, 1995: Johnson on fire again in M's win
- Moscow-Pullman Daily News, Seattle Post-Intelligencer, Oct. 4, 1995: Ayala's collapse costs Mariners in opener
- Seattle Times, April 13, 2008: Hey, Mariners fans, enough about Bobby Ayala and Alex Rodriguez, already
Players/Coaches Featured: 905
Made the Majors: 611 - 67.5%-X
Never Made Majors: 294-32.5%
5+ Seasons in the Majors: 273-X
10+ Seasons in the Minors: 163