"I know how to pitch in the big leagues," Nagy told The Associated Press after his 11-1 victory over New York. "You got to try to keep your concentration out there."
Nagy kept his concentration that year, racking up a total of 17 wins for the Indians. It was the first of three seasons Nagy would reach that win mark. He also reached the All-Star game that year, also for the first of three times.
After a career that spanned 14 big league seasons, Nagy is now passing on his knowledge of how to pitch in the big league to others, in the big leagues. Nagy is in his second season as pitching coach for the Arizona Diamondbacks.
Nagy's career began in 1988, taken by the Indians in the first round, 17th overall, out of the University of Connecticut.
After playing out 1988 with Team USA, Nagy joined the Indians in 1989 at single-A Kinston. He moved up to AA Canton by the end of that year and major league Cleveland by the end of the next.
Nagy got called up in late July, going 2-4, with a 5.91 ERA the rest of the way. He didn't get his first win, though, until his sixth try.
"I was close twice before," Nagy told reporters after that first win. "I'm just real excited right now."
It was the first of 129 total big league wins for Nagy.
Nagy came back in 1991 to go 10-15, with a 4.13 ERA. He then showed why he was a first-round pick in 1992, going 17-10, with a 2.96 ERA, earning that first All-Star selection.
Then he ran into arm troubles. In 1993, Nagy started 2-5, with an ERA of 6.31 in nine starts. Shoulder problems, though, led to arthroscopic surgery in June. Nagy made it back, just for one game, though, at the end of the season.
Nagy returned to form in 1994, going 10-8, with a 3.45 ERA in the shortened season. In 1995, the first of two World Series years, Nagy went 16-6, with a 4.55 ERA. In the World Series, Nagy went seven innings in Game 3, but gave up five earned runs. The Indians, though, won the game.
Nagy's 1996 was even better, 17-5, with a 3.41 ERA. He also came in fourth in the Cy Young balloting and not only made the All Star game, but started it.
"There's a lot of factors that go into my winning," Nagy told The Associated Press in June, after his 10th win, "and the bullpen is one of them. We get timely hits and the bullpen finishes the job."
Nagy and the Indians returned to the World Series in 1997. In another Game 3, Nagy went six innings, giving up another five runs. Then, in Game 7, Nagy came on in the 10th inning, finishing off that frame, but giving up the game-winning and series-winning run in the 11th.
Nagy came back for two more full seasons with the Indians, then injuries took their toll. He continued playing into 2003, last playing with the Padres.
After returning to the Indians in 2004 as a special assistant for baseball operations, Nagy hit the field again in 2006, becoming pitching coach with the Angels at AAA Salt Lake. In 2010, Nagy served as pitching coach at AAA Columbus. Then, in 2011, he returned to the majors as pitching coach for the Diamondbacks.
"He's very, very competitive," Gibson told The Connecticut Post in May 2012. "He has a real burning desire for excellence. He's got a great approach with his players. He's very calm about organizing his thoughts. You could see why he was a good pitcher, because he stays on a path. He doesn't get influenced by the pressure of things."
- Schenectady Gazette, wire report, Sept. 19, 1990: Indians 8, Brewers 3
- Norwalk Hour, Associated Press, April 18, 1992: Nagy, Indians hand Yankees 11-1 defeat
- Lewiston Morning Tribune, Associated Press, June 11, 1996: Nagy earns 10th win as Indians top A's
- Connecticut Post, May 13, 2012: Nagy's calm reassurance a plus for D'backs
Cards Featured: 765/880 - 86.9%
Players/Coaches Featured: 776
Made the Majors: 527 - 68%-X
Never Made the Majors:249-32%
5+ Seasons in the Majors: 232-X
10+ Seasons in the Minors: 145