Eiland went seven innings in that August 1988 contest, leaving with a 5-1 lead. Eiland's Yankees lost 6-5.
"It's happened to me before," Eiland told The New York Times. "That could have been me out there. It's part of the game. It happens."
Eiland went on to see time in 10 major league seasons, starting 70 big league games. But wins would be at a premium, he would only pick up 12.
Eiland, though, would go on to oversee many more wins, as pitching coach for the team that first brought him to the majors, the Yankees and elsewhere. Eiland's three season stint with the Yankees also included overseeing a world title. He then did the same in the same role with the Royals.
Eiland's career began in 1987, taken by the Yankees in the seventh round out of the University of Florida. He split that first year between short-season Oneonta and single-A Fort Lauderdale.
In his second season, Eiland hit AA Albany, AAA Columbus and got that first start in the Bronx. With the Yankees that year, Eiland got three starts and no decisions. His second and third starts were less successful, totaling 5.2 innings and eight runs given up.
Eiland returned for six more starts in 1989, getting his first win against three losses. Eiland got five starts in 1990, going 1-2. That September, Eiland got another hard-luck no decision, throwing 8.1 innings of shutout ball. The Yankees, though, couldn't score either.
''You can't pitch any better than he pitched,'' Yankee manager Stump Merrill told The Times after that September 1990 outing.
In 1991, Eiland got into 18 games, 13 starts. He also went 2-5, with a 5.33 ERA. He was also released that next off-season, signing with the Padres for 1992.
Eiland got seven starts for the Padres that year, going 0-2, with a 5.67 ERA. He also got one home run, in is first major league at bat that April. "I couldn't believe it," Eiland told reporters of the home run. "Strange things happen."
Nine more starts for the Padres in 1993 and Eiland was back to the minors until 1995. That year, back with the Yankees, Eiland got a single start and three relief appearances.
Then came two more seasons back in the minors. In 1998, Eiland returned to the majors, in a single start for Tampa Bay. That he didn't get more opportunities that year, upset Eiland, according to The Orlando Sentinel. He went 13-5 at AAA Durham with a 2.99 ERA.
"I think I've been labeled by some people,'' Eiland told The Sentinel. "You reach a certain age and everyone thinks you stop improving and you can't do the job."
Eiland, though, didn't do well in that one start, giving up six earned runs in 2.2 innings. It also came against the Yankees. In 1999 Eiland got more time, 15 starts, the most of his major league career.
Going into that year, Eiland also got some screen time, serving as a pitching double for Kevin Costner in the movie For the Love of the Game, The Sentinel wrote.
Eiland finished out his big league career in 2000, with 17 appearances, 10 starts. He went 2-3, with a 7.24 ERA for the Devil Rays.
Eiland's post-playing career began by 2003, back with the Yankees. He coached that year in the Gulf Coast League, moving to short-season Staten Island for 2004. He hit AA Trenton in 2005, AAA Scranton in 2007 and arrived back in the Bronx in 2008. Eiland stayed through 2010, when he was dismissed.
"Dave spent his entire coaching career with the Yankees organization, and there is little doubt the impact he had on a great number of pitchers during his tenure," Yankees manager Joe Girardi told reporters in a statement after Eiland's dismissal.
"He was a passionate and knowledgeable pitching coach on the major league level," Girardi added in the statement, "and he played a valuable role in our team's achievements in recent years. I wish him continued success moving forward as his baseball career continues to evolve."
Eiland then went on to join the Royals as pitching coach in 2012. He stayed there through 2017, helping the club to the 2015 World Series title. He then spent two seasons as pitching coach for the Mets. In 2020, he served as a manager in the Constellation Energy League based out of Sugar Land, Texas.
- New York Times, Aug. 4, 1988: Eiland's Debut Is Ruined As Righetti Blows Lead
- New York Times, Sept. 11, 1990: Eiland's Effort Is Wasted
- Reading Eagle, news services, April 12, 1992: First at-bat memorable for Padres hurler Eiland
- Orlando Sentinel, Sept. 26, 1998: Former Team Pounds Tampa Bay's Eiland
- Orlando Sentinel, March 19, 1999: Costner Turns To Eiland
- ESPN.com, Oct. 26, 2010: Yankees fire Dave Eiland