It was his eighth major league start.
"I'm happy I finally got the win," Mitchell told The Associated Press after the game, adding later, "I had a chance for the shutout, but I didn't get it. That's Okay. Now I can go out and have confidence."
Less than four years earlier, Mitchell was simply happy to be alive.
In November 1983, Mitchell and two Red Sox system teammates, Scott Skripko and Tony Latham, went out on a fishing trip with the owner of the boat, Mark Zastowny. It was on their day off between Red Sox instructional league games.
The boat capsized. For 22 hours, Mitchell clung to a cooler and part of a life preserver. Skripko survived 20 hours before being rescued. Latham, who'd played the previous season a single-A Winston-Salem, and the boat owner Zastowny did not survive.
"Someday," Mitchell told The Boston Globe days after the accident, "this is going to be very, very difficult to live with. But right now, we're just glad to be alive."
Mitchell's career in professional baseball had begun just months before, taken by the Red Sox in the seventh round of the draft out Overton High School in Tennessee. The Red Sox were the same organization that signed his brother Charlie Mitchell the year before.
Mitchell played that first season at short-season Elmira, going 5-6 with a 4.90 ERA. Having survived the accident, Mitchell went on to a 16-9 at Winter Haven in 1984 and a 12-8 record at AA New Britain in 1985.
For 1986, Mitchell arrived in the Mets system, dealt there in an eight-player deal. He played the year at AAA Tidewater, making his major league debut in September.
Mitchell got into four games for the Mets that year, giving up four earned runs in 10 innings. He returned for 1987, getting that first win and two others. He went 3-6, with a 4.11 ERA.
He returned for both 1988 and 1989, but for only one game the first year, and two the next. In December 1989, Mitchell was again traded, to the Orioles.
The next spring, Mitchell worked to make the Baltimore roster and pitched well enough to get noticed, getting into 24 games that year, starting 17.
"You're happy you threw the ball well, but you're trying to make the team," Mitchell told the Associated Press late in spring training. "You want to pitch perfect every time. You want to get everybody out."
Mitchell went 6-6 on the year for the Orioles, with a 4.64 ERA. In early July, he got his first win of the year, and first win since 1987.
Against the White Sox July 7, Mitchell went eight innings, giving up one run. That was after an outing where he went two and gave up six. The implications were obvious, Mitchell told The Chicago Tribune after the White Sox outing.
"I'm not stupid," Mitchell told The Tribune. "I sensed I needed a good outing, and that if I did not contribute, I might not be around here very much longer."
While Mitchell stuck around for the rest of the season, it was his last in the majors. He played 1991 with the Mariners at AAA Calgary and continued playing in affiliated and independent ball through 1998.
In 2009, Mitchell was in his hometown of Nashville working for a municipal castings company, according to Sports Illustrated. The magazine retold the story of the 1983 boat accident after another boat accident claimed the lives of three football players.
When Sports Illustrated caught up with Mitchell, he was married, with three children. His then-13-year-old son was named Johnny Latham Mitchell.
"I don't think about that experience all the time anymore," Mitchell told Sports Illustrated. "But it will never leave me. Never."
- Beaver County Times, Boston Globe, Nov. 6, 1983: Nightmare: Two survive 20-hour ordeal after boat capsizes
- Schenectady Gazette, Associated Press, June 20, 1987: Mets Hit Four Homers As Mitchell Beats Phils
- Spokane Spokesman-Review, Associated Press, April 2, 1990: Mariners lose early lead, lose fourth to San Diego
- Chicago Tribune, July 8, 1990: Orioles' Starter Sinks The Sox, Saves His Job
- Sports Illustrated, March 4, 2009: Tragedy at sea brings back chilling memories of Anthony Latham
- 131 - Charlie Mitchell, Family Trade, 5/25/10
Players/Coaches Featured: 473Made the Majors: 319 - 67%-X
Never Made the Majors:154-33%
5+ Seasons in the Majors: 131-X
10+ Seasons in the Minors: 113